‘Abuja Declaration target remains a pipe dream for Zimbabwe’

By Vanessa Gonye, Newsday


CWGH Executive Director, Itai Rusike

HARARE, Apr. 2, (NewsDayLive) – The Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) says Zimbabwe’s hope of achieving the Abuja Declaration target on healthcare funding will likely remain a pipe dream as allocations and fiscal disbursements to the health sector have remained below 15% of the national budget.

Signed on April 27, 2001 when African governments pledged to allocate at least 15% of their annual budgets to the health sector, the Abuja Declaration was meant to strengthen Africa’s health systems and ensure they are adequately capacitated to manage natural disasters.

Speaking on the country’s failure to meet the allocation as stipulated by the declaration on Tuesday, CWGH executive director Itai Rusike said despite progressive increases in budgetary allocations towards the 15% allocation for health, the fiscal disbursements have been inadequate to keep the system afloat.

“The 15% mark has never been attained, with government spending on health care as a percentage of total public expenditure increasing only from 10.6% in 2022 to 11.2% in 2023,” Rusike said.

“This poor financing for health has been another sore issue for the health workers as they interface with clients they cannot adequately serve.

“The majority of clients seen in the public sector remain without comprehensive healthcare except for a few selected diseases and conditions which receive vertical funding (HIV/Aids, TB, Malaria, maternal and child conditions).

“Despite the recent moves towards integration, community health workers get frustrated rendering inadequate service and have, therefore, been moving to more resourced jurisdictions.”

He said the situation means that universal access to health remains beyond reach, until the budgetary bottlenecks have been adequately addressed .

Rusike also noted that the past two decades have been characterised by massive outward migration of health, education, social and other professionals due to the protracted social, political and economic demise.

“This state of affairs has greatly impacted the government’s functionality with the high levels of corruption taking resources away from where they are needed most,” he said.

“The results have been telling in the multi system collapse including public health infrastructure and services.”

Health minister Douglas Mombeshora last month claimed that several key health indicators had shown notable improvements.

“We are particularly proud of the advancements in areas like maternal and child health, disease prevention, and healthcare infrastructure,” Mombeshora said.

“Looking ahead, we remain fully committed to our shared vision of increasing access to quality healthcare for all Zimbabweans.”

Revitalizing PHC4UHC by 2030 and rebuilding a fragile health system from the bottom up

… Addressing Zimbabwe’s Health System Demise and Brain Drain

By Itai Rusike

This article was first published in the Medicus Mundi Switzerland (MMS) Bulletin, #172 March 2025

The health and social services must function optimally for a country to realize social cohesion, economic growth, and be in tandem with the global health and security agenda. The current situation of investing in education and professional training and then “donating” the young and able-bodied products to already established, functional health systems located in wealthy countries is a luxury that poor economies like Zimbabwe cannot afford. The remaining few health workers remain frustrated and incapacitated to deliver effective care resulting in the subdued population health status currently obtaining in Zimbabwe.


CHWs in Zimbabwe participating at the National Health Financing Dialogue – @Itai Rusike

The development and transition of the health system in Zimbabwe over the decades

Zimbabwe has documented a number of transitions in its healthcare delivery system. In the pre-colonial era and before introduction of conventional medicine, traditional and spiritual methods of diagnosis and treatments were complemented by diets and taboos that supported the health across the life course. There were specific foods and medicinal plants for the pregnant women, newborns, young children, adolescents, young adults and the elderly. Various medicine men and women and the older uncles and aunts would oversee these, but there were no formally trained health professionals.

The colonial era came with introduction of western medicine but was limited mostly to the urban, mining and agricultural areas, and left the rural areas to continue their various traditional medical practices to address ailments. This saw the introduction of formal training of the natives in health especially nursing, environmental health to complement those introduced by the settlers. The first African Zimbabwean doctor was Samuel Parirenyatwa.

At its Independence in 1980, and just two years after the Alma Ata Declaration the government premised its health delivery system on the concept and philosophy of Primary Health Care (PHC) (WHO, UNICEF, 1978); greatly expanding the reach of conventional medicine to the rest of the country in terms of more health institutions and a defined healthcare workforce for the public health system, to be followed by a health workforce “establishment”. This was after the realization that the majority of the population resided in the rural areas and yet health care was centralized in the few urban centers. A number of policy pronouncements guided the process of ensuring the goal of “health for all by 2000”; including the white paper on health of 1981, “Planning for Equity in Health” of 1985, and the accompanying decentralization saw much improvement in the population access to affordable and quality health care.

In the 1997-2007 national health strategy, 85% of the population had access to a health facility within 10Km. The public health system catered for about 80% of the population through central government, local government, church and NGO run institutions. The life expectancy, maternal, child and general mortality in the population greatly reduced while health status and other favorable indicators improved leading to the country attaining notable health and welfare standards.

At its Independence in 1980, and just two years after the Alma Ata Declaration the government premised its health delivery system on the concept and philosophy of Primary Health Care (PHC).

Current situation

A number of challenges have almost reversed this progress and development of Zimbabwe’s health sector of which have been decades of socio-economic and political challenges that impacted negatively on health and related social services. These have been compounded by weaknesses within the system characterized by rigidity within the governance and management levels and resultant failures to adapt to the changes. The health workforce bear the brunt of these systemic weaknesses and failures and so after the demise of almost all the health system building blocks trained and experienced staff have been leaving in large numbers to join the private sector, neighboring countries and the diaspora. The major complaints have been poor remuneration, limited access to tools of the trade, as the health institutions continue to have stock outs of medicines and major supplies.

The weak governance systems also mean that there is no organized systems to adequately plan for and deploy the few trained personnel to benefit their populations, nor benefit the country when they emigrate to other countries.

The country and health system failed to adequately adopt to major transitions and have left healthcare workers with little or no support in terms of capacitation to cope, protection from infections within institutions and during public health crises, nor financial cover to make their work and contribution worthwhile. Among the transitions have been the structural adjustment programs, (ESAP) of the mid 1980’s, the HIV pandemic of the early 1990’s, and now the socioeconomic and political situation since the turn of the millennium. There have also been demographic, epidemiological and technological transitions in line with population increases, disease trends and this combination of major changes required a corresponding governance and management structure that responds with timely and effective policy and legislative responses that ensure sustainable service delivery with the health workforce at the center- being a services sector.

However the decentralization of early 1990’s was not followed by devolution and healthcare worker issues have continued to be centralized, fueling frustration and health worker exodus and thus almost emptying the institutions of their health workforce.

Despite progressive increases in budgetary allocations towards the 15% allocation for health, (Abuja, 2001), the fiscal disbursements have been inadequate to keep the system afloat. The 15% mark has never been attained, with Government spending on health care as a percentage of total public expenditure increasing only from 10.6% in 2022 to 11.2% in 2023.

This poor financing for health has been another sore issue for the health workers as they interface with clients they cannot adequately serve. The majority of clients seen in the public sector remain without comprehensive care except for a few selected diseases and conditions which receive vertical funding (HIV/Aids, TB, Malaria, maternal and child conditions). Despite the recent moves to integration Health Communitiy Workers (HCWs) get frustrated rendering inadequate service and have therefore been moving to more resourced jurisdictions.

This situation means that universal access to health remains beyond reach, until and unless the complex health situation is effectively addressed. The recent developments of wars, climate crises and the major shifts in the donor landscape well before the earlier warning of the 2030 deadline requires urgent action on the part of government and the health ministry.

The majority of clients seen in the public sector remain without comprehensive care except for a few selected diseases and conditions which receive vertical funding (HIV/Aids, TB, Malaria, maternal and child conditions).

Causes of the global health care workforce shortages

A number of factors are responsible for the current situation including the demographic and epidemic transitions. The inadequate health workforce in developed countries cannot cope with the combined complexities of chronic diseases compounded by ageing populations. Meanwhile in developing countries it’s the opposite in that the epidemiological transition has not been effectively addressed as they remain with a huge burden of infections, emerging and re-emerging diseases, unchecked chronic/noncommunicable diseases which include injuries, mental health conditions and substance abuse.

The demographics are characteristically young populations but with limited access to education and training opportunities due to weak health, education and other social systems. The weak governance systems also mean that there is no organized system to adequately plan for and deploy the few trained personnel to benefit their populations, nor benefit the country when they emigrate to other countries. The case in point being that of the expatriates deployed to Zimbabwe during the post-independence era and in recent times, the Cuban health, education etc brigades whose deployment is regulated by their state, and follows signed agreements with the receiving countries. The World Health Organization (WHO) Global code on recruitment of health care workers has not been heeded, neither is it enforceable in the member states as is the framework convention on tobacco control, (FCTC) and the international health regulations, (IHR, 2005, 20012), both of which are binding.

The current situation of investing in education and professional training and then “donating” the young and able-bodied products to already established, functional health systems located in wealthy countries is a luxury that poor economies like Zimbabwe cannot afford.

Social and economic consequences of a shortage of HCWs for countries with weaker health systems
In Zimbabwe, the past two decades have been characterized by massive outward migration of health, education, social and other professionals due to the protracted social political and economic demise. This state of affairs has greatly impacted on government’s functionality with the high levels of corruption taking resources away from where they are needed most. The results have been telling in the multi system collapse including public health infrastructure and services.

As a result, the major determinants of health have become severely neglected, causing outbreaks and adding a considerable burden of preventable diseases and conditions. For a largely unemployed population, the paradox is the huge out of pocket expenditure for preventable ailments while the collapsed system cannot serve the clients. The result has been adverse health indicators across the population with considerable premature, avoidable and excess mortality.

How do HCWs experience the effects of staff shortage?

Healthcare workers are supposed to work as teams and seldom in isolation. At central, city and provincial hospitals there used to be multidisciplinary teams of 2-4 consultants per firm, with registrars, senior and junior residents, then the nursing team, physiotherapists, nutritionist etc., but currently there may just be one doctor -and few nurses. The workload becomes unmanageable and each shift is taxing as oftentimes one cadre has to carry out the tasks of 3 or 4 others, with no one to discuss the patient condition, treatment options nor debrief.

This has resulted in burnout of the few cadres whose recognition and remuneration has not increased significantly despite the increased demand on them. The patients and their relatives often accuse them of blocking services and pilfering medicines and supplies for their benefit when in fact it’s the nationwide corruption that has stripped the system and caused the neglect. At the districts and remote clinics often one nurse has to oversee a whole unit and this compromises patient care, accurate documentation and patient follow up. There is little time for continuous professional development as most of the time the staff is overwhelmed and working solo.

The patients and their relatives often accuse them of blocking services and pilfering medicines and supplies for their benefit when in fact it’s the nationwide corruption that has stripped the system and caused the neglect.

How effective is the WHO Global Code of Practice on international recruitment of HCWs?

For countries like Zimbabwe the global and even the WHO Afro regional office pronouncements on preventing or minimizing health worker migration have been ineffective. There has to be some acknowledgment to the sending country to compensate for its investment in the professional and this to be ring-fenced to further enable training and or improving the working environment of those who remain in-country. Deliberate efforts must be made to invest in addressing the demise of the health systems that have bled too many healthcare workers by the major receiving and wealthy nations.

There has to be some acknowledgment to the sending country to compensate for its investment in the professional and this to be ring-fenced to further enable training and or improving the working environment of those who remain in-country.

What are the potential solutions to address HCWs crisis/shortage long term?

– Address the work environment by re-investing and revitalizing the health delivery system across the WHO’s six building blocks of a health delivery system, and in tandem with a revitalized primary health care for universal health access (PHC4UHC, CWGH, PHCPI, 2022).
– Implement the health financing reform in line with the dwindling donor support and the critical need for a robust local financing architecture.
– Improve the governance and management of the healthcare workforce and ensure that well trained health professionals are in charge and make decisions rather than the corruptly appointed management.

The latter have been competing with and further frustrating the healthcare workers and yet remain without a sound understanding of the system and its complexities. Given the extent of the demise and the high turnover of staff over a protracted period, there may be need to bring in some of the old guard, (retired but not tired) to hand hold and mentor the young inexperienced staff. This can help restore the dignity of the profession, improve confidence, service delivery and patient outcomes.

The government must also ensure implementation of the Constitutional provisions for health and its determinants, enforce the public health act and enforce mandates across all sectors that hold key determinants of health in order to effectively prevent disease and promote health. The result will be more manageable workloads for the reduced staff. Furthermore, there has to be strategies that address the huge and unchecked burden of non-communicable diseases, injuries and mass trauma casualties, mental health, substance abuse and climate induced health issues that have not yet received attention but are over-loading the limited health workforce.

Itai Rusike is the Executive Director, Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) – Zimbabwe. Itai is a Public Health Activist with more than 20 years’ experience organising involvement of communities in health actions in Zimbabwe. He is a member and chairperson of various health related committees, along with being the Vice-President of Medicus Mundi International Network.

For the full bulletin, follow link : https://www.medicusmundi.ch/en/advocacy/publications/mms-bulletin/health-workforce-shortage-are-there-potential/kapitel-1/addressing-zimbabwe%E2%80%99s-health-system-demise

Carnage in NGOs, clinics

By Problem Masau and Vanessa Gonye

UNCERTAINTY has gripped thousands of employees in the non-governmental organisation (NGO) and civil society organisation (CSO) sectors after they were told to go home following United States President Donald Trump’s issuance of an executive order to freeze foreign aid for 90 days.

Zimbabwe has thousands of NGOs and CSOs across a range of sectors, with the majority of them getting huge chunks of their funding from the US.

The categories that have been severely affected are humanitarian aid, service organisations and political governance.

According to the 2019 Labour Force and Child Labour Survey conducted by the Zimbabwe National StatisticsAgency, the NGO sector accounts for 1,2% of the total employed persons in the country, which translates to an aggregate figure of 17 643 formal jobs.

The figure could, however, be larger amid indications that the sector was the second largest employer in Zimbabwe after government.

Employees who spoke on condition of anonymity yesterday told NewsDay that they were uncertain about their continued employment after Trump’s 90-day review.

“We are in a difficult position. We don’t know what will happen after the 90 days,” one of them said.

“I also do not know where I will get money for rentals since our salaries were also frozen.”

Zimbabwe Nurses Association secretary-general Enock Dongo told NewsDay that nurses, who were working at local clinics under the US President’s Emergency Plan for Aids Relief (PEPFAR) programme, have been told not to come to work.

“We have members who have been working at local clinics who have been told not to report to duty today (yesterday).

“Those people are under emotional stress and also the patients who were waiting for them are affected,” he said.

“What the Trump administration has done is very disrespectful. You cannot just wake up and tell people not to come to work without notice.

“Even if the Zimbabwean government wants to chip in, it needs to prepare first. Africa should wake up and not rely on Western funds.”

Most of the workers were told to surrender vehicles and gadgets belonging to the NGOs.

Crisis in Zimbabwe Coalition (CiZC) director Blessing Vava said it was high time the country and the NGO sector came up with ways to deal with national problems.

“I think it is an opportunity for us to go back to the basics and build organic movements, where voluntarism and sacrifice are at the centre,” he said.

“Trump is doing what he is doing for his country and the American people.

“We are Zimbabweans and can never be American, so let’s focus on fixing our problems instead.”

The US embassy in Zimbabwe issued a statement confirming that the executive order was now in effect affecting aid programmes in the country.

The embassy noted Zimbabwe’s recent progress in combating HIV, noting that the country has achieved the global 95/95/95 targets — a benchmark for HIV testing, treatment and viral suppression.

However, the embassy called on government to take greater responsibility for sustaining these gains.

“They urgently need to be focused on buying antiretroviral therapy (ART) and getting nurses in clinics. They can do this,” the statement read.

Meanwhile, stakeholders in the health sector have expressed concern over massive reliance on donor funding as anything can happen leaving the masses in danger.

Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said the consequences would be catastrophic to patients and communities in Zimbabwe that depended on US support for lifesaving interventions as they would face disruptions to critical services.

“It is risky and unsustainable for a country to depend substantially on external partners as donors can withdraw financial support anytime should their interests shift for some reason or other,” he said.

“It is very sad that when a country is highly dependent on external aid, health priority in government spending tends to fall in line with increased aid.

“Development assistance for health has crowded out government resources and created donor dependence.”

Health expert Martha Tholanah said the executive order was a wake-up call for Zimbabwe.

“Having such panic means our reliance on foreign funding is too heavy. We need more domestic resources for health from the national Treasury,” she said.

“Partners should complement the government, not the other way round. I hope we get our support for treatment sorted such that we never have to be in such distress when a foreign partner decides to withdraw their support.”

Approximately 1,2 million people in Zimbabwe are on HIV treatment and around 90% of HIV-positive pregnant women receive ART.

The developments mean children are under the risk of contracting HIV if mothers stop taking their medication and many more people will be affected given the state of the health sector in Zimbabwe.

By the end of 2023, the US had poured in over US$300 million in active programmes in Zimbabwe, according to the United States Agency for International Development foreign aid portal.

Finance minister Mthuli Ncube has indicated that the government will fund the gap left by the US through tax. -Newsday

US withdrawal from WHO spells doom for Zimbabwe’s Health Sector

https://www.newsday.co.zw/local-news/article/200037270/us-withdrawal-from-who-spells-doom-for-zims-health-sector

Article By Vanessa Gonye |

ZIMBABWEAN health experts have raised concern over the newly-inaugurated United States President Donald Trump’s decision to withdraw his country from the World Health Organisation (WHO) saying the world’s largest economy was one of the major funders of the United Nations agency.

Trump accused WHO of mishandling the COVID-19 pandemic and other international health crises, adding that it had also failed to act independently of the inappropriate political influence of member States.

“World Health Organisation ripped us off, everybody ripped off the United States. It’s not going to happen anymore,” Trump said during the signing of an executive order on the withdrawal, shortly after his inauguration to a second term on Monday.

Analysts told NewsDay yesterday that Trump’s decision will affect the country’s health delivery programme funded through WHO.

Medical and Dental Private Practitioners of Zimbabwe Association president Johannes Marisa said the withdrawal would be a serious blow to international health systems.

“In terms of disease outbreaks, like recently with the Mpox, with the COVID-19, with other diseases, measles and so forth, WHO has to do serious surveillance, has to do serious communication, undertake contact tracing and has to do serious case management.

“These programmes or strategies were funded by WHO, which is sponsored by the US among other countries meaning failure to access money or to have adequate funding, the World Health Organisation will be on its knees,” he said.

Itai Rusike, Community Working Group on Health executive director expressed hope for a way out of the impasse between the US government and WHO.

Rusike said WHO being the global authority on health required all the support both technically and materially to fully execute its mandate.

“The withdrawal of the US implies it will not provide the support which we hear amounts to about a fifth of the WHO budget and this is of concern when health challenges are increasing.

“This has considerable impact on the organisation’s operations at all levels and may result in reduced support for our country when the fragility of our health system demands more resources,” he said.

Rusike said Trump’s decision served as a reminder to governments to quickly move towards self-sustenance.

Tendai Westerhof, Pan-African Positive Women’s Coalition Zimbabwe’s national director, echoed the same sentiments highlighting issues of sustainability.

“80% of our funding comes from external donors and we only have 20% that we mobilise locally. So really, this calls for us as countries, especially us in the developing world, to be not too dependent on external funding.

“We appreciate that the US was funding PEPFAR and a lot of money was coming into countries through PEPFAR, through the global fund and WHO, it’s a world organisation that does not discriminate,” she said.

Westerhof added: “We must look internally and be innovative to see how best we can increase our internal domestic funding to the health budget in particular.”

In a statement yesterday, WHO director Tedros Adhanom Ghebreyesus said news of the US’s withdrawal from the organisation was regrettable.

He said WHO played a crucial role in protecting the health and security of the world’s people by addressing the root causes of diseases building stronger health systems, and detecting, preventing and responding to health emergencies.

“The United States was a founding member of WHO in 1948 and has participated in shaping and governing WHO’s work ever since, alongside 193 other member States, including through its active participation in the World Health Assembly and Executive Board,” he said.

Tedros expressed hope the US will reconsider and engage them “in constructive dialogue to maintain the partnership between the US and WHO.” –  Newsday

‘Healthcare will operate on shoestring budget’

By Gamuchirai Nyamuziwa | Dec. 6, 2024

ZIMBABWE’S budgetary allocation of ZiG28,3 billion to the health sector for 2025 is insufficient to address the severe challenges facing the public health system, experts have warned.

Last week, Finance, Economic Development and Investment Promotion minister Mthuli Ncube allocated 10,2% of the national budget to the Ministry of Health and Child Care, falling significantly short of the Abuja Declaration target, which calls on African nations to dedicate at least 15% of their budgets to healthcare.

Itai Rusike, executive director of the Community Working Group on Health, expressed concern over the declining share of health spending in government expenditure.

He noted that the allocation of 10,2% represents a drop from 10,6% in 2024.

“Health spending as a share of total government expenditure is an indicator of the priority given to health,” Rusike said.

He stressed the need for increased investment in building a robust and accessible health system.

Achieving Universal Health Coverage (UHC), which aims to ensure access to quality health services without financial hardship, requires strong public funding and a commitment to treating healthcare as a fundamental right. The government’s healthcare spending, projected at 2,1% of gross domestic product (GDP) in 2025, has fallen sharply from 4% in 2024.

This is far below global averages, as highlighted in the World Health Organisation’s 2023 Global Expenditure on Health report, which showed high-income countries spent an average of US$4 001 per capita on health in 2021, compared to US$45 in low-income countries like Zimbabwe.

“Increasing health expenditure in tandem with the increased population, disease burden and new national development goals remains a challenge to the health sector,” Rusike said.

“No country can make significant progress towards universal health coverage without relying on a dominant share of public funds.

“It is therefore critically important to ensure that the health system is adequately resourced and that resources are efficiently and optimally utilised.

“Government also spends a relatively small share of its GDP on health care.”

Rusike said the allocations fell short of what is necessary for a transformative impact on health care delivery.

“The budget earmarks funds for vital interventions: ZiG3,5 billion for the construction and rehabilitation of health facilities, ZiG290 million for medical equipment, and ZiG150 million for ambulances,” Rusike said.

“Moreover, given the unstable macroeconomic situation, it is important that allocations be disbursed timeously.

“This is critical especially given the fact that by the first half of 2024, the Ministry of Health and Child Care had only received 26,9% of its total allocation for the year; and by September it had received 52,6% of the total budget,” he added.

Rusike said the budget lacked adequate provisions for sexual and reproductive health services, particularly for women and adolescents in rural areas.

Edinah Masiyiwa, executive director at Women’s Action Group, said the budget should have prioritised a well-funded post abortion care programme, among other important issues.

“I call upon the Ministry of Health and Child Care to invest enough resources in health centres so that women can access quality services,” she said.

“A study carried out by the Guttmacher Institute revealed that health centres did not have essential supplies for post-abortion care such as misoprostol, blood and antibiotics. It is important for the national health budget to ensure all the supplies are available for post-abortion care if we are serious about saving lives,” Masiyiwa noted.

This oversight perpetuated existing inequalities and limited women’s ability to make informed choices about their health and family planning.

“The sector is confronted with ensuring that the poor and vulnerable who include women, new-born babies, children and adolescents are also able to afford quality health services,” he said. (The Zimbabwe Independent)