Concerns over amendments to the Health Services Act.

Credit : Newsday

THERE are fears that the recently signed Health Service Amendment Act could trample on the rights of health workers.

Speaking to NewsDay, Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike  said the Act is neither democratic nor consultative.

He said workers in the public health sector  are now disadvantaged in several ways, since now they cannot strike and bargain collectively.

“It is unfortunate that health workers are caught in the middle of a system that is slow to respond to their needs and ethical pressures not to take collective job action,” Rusike said.

“The unpopular Health Services Act will most likely exacerbate the exodus of health workers from the country thereby putting extra pressure on those who will remain on their jobs.”

He urged government to address the conditions of service for health workers to plug the brain drain.

While there are no exact statistics on the number of health professionals who left the country in 2021, the Zimbabwe Nurses Association put the figure at just over 2000.

Last year, government announced plans to ban doctors and nurses from embarking on job action lasting more than three days under new proposed amendments to the Health Services Act.

Call for equitable health access

Credit Venessa Gonye : Zimbabwe Independent

HEALTH experts have called for equitable health access for marginalised groups such as rural people, women and children.

This comes as the world yesterday commemorated the International Universal Health Coverage (UHC) Day, which falls on December 12 annually.

Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said a country’s health system should work for everyone regardless of their financial status.

“Equitable health coverage puts women, children, adolescents, and the most vulnerable first because they face the most significant barriers to essential care. We all deserve a health system we know will be there for us throughout our lifespan. Trusted health systems provide high-quality services in primary care clinics and hospitals, equip and support frontline community health workers, and offer transparent health,” Rusike said.

He said Zimbabwe was affected by a decline in standards at the country’s major referral hospital, as well as the brain-drain in key personnel.

 

 

“UHC goes hand-in-hand with empowering communities to build healthy environments that promote holistic physical, mental and social well-being. Investing in #HealthForAll is the backbone of a prosperous society. Increasing public financing for health and reducing out-of-pocket health costs save lives, build resilience against pandemic threats, and advances Sustainable Development Goals beyond health.

World Health Organization (WHO) director AMR Global Co-ordination Haileyesus Getahun said challenges threatening a “healthy future for all” could not be addressed by the healthcare sector alone, but by a united and collaborative multi-sectoral response to ensure health security for everyone.

“The one health approach is an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals, and ecosystems. It recognizes that the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and interdependent,” Getahun said.

In August this year, WHO expressed concern over Zimbabwe’s slow pace in improving UHC, which is part of an initiative to ensure everyone has access to proper health services.

2023 Health Budget insufficient

HEALTH experts yesterday said Finance minister Mthuli Ncube’s $473,8 billion budget allocation towards the provision of health care services was grossly inadequate to fund the sector’s critical needs.

Ncube announced a $4,5 trillion budget on Thursday with 11% going towards health. Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said the health sector remains grossly underfunded.

“The health budget remains grossly inadequate to fund the critical needs in the health sector,” Rusike said.

“The current health financing model remains unsustainable as it heavily relies on external financing as well as out-of-pocket spending.”

“In spite of the huge external support from development partners, there is still a huge financing gap in the health sector in the country which calls for greater innovation and commitment by the government to sustainably address it.”

Dental Private Practitioners Association of Zimbabwe president Johannes Marisa said: “The health sector budget is an improvement from last year but of course when you are benchmarking with the Abuja Declaration you still realise that it falls short of the stipulated 15%.

“We hope the budget is going to address the mass brain drain that is underway in Zimbabwe where we are losing experienced and skilled workers to greener pastures.”

In April 2001, African Union countries met in Abuja and pledged to allocate at least 15% of their annual budgets to improve the health sector and urged donor countries to scale up support.

Years of underfunding of the country’s health sector was laid bare when COVID-19 hit the country as acute shortages of critical and lifesaving equipment such as ventilators and intensive care beds were exposed.

 

Some South African officials have accused Zimbabweans of straining that country’s health sector.

In his 2023 national budget, Ncube the allocation to health was meant to improve health provision.

 “In 2023, the budget has set aside 11% of total expenditures towards the health sector notwithstanding financial constraints, Government is committed to the provision of quality health services, as evidenced by the ongoing construction and rehabilitation of health facilities,” Ncube said.

 “In 2023, the budget has set aside 11% of total expenditures towards the health sector and the objective is to eventually meet the Abuja Declaration of 15%. This is necessary to attain Vision 2030 of becoming an upper middle-income economy.”

“In 2023, the sector is projected to receive US$212,9 million from the development partners towards the same areas.”

Ncube admitted that the health sector has been hard hit by mass exodus of health professionals.

“Government is, however, addressing this challenge through continuous review of both monetary and non-monetary incentives in order to attract and retain medical personnel.”

Brief Post Budget Analysis 2023 CWGH

 

The 2023 Health Budget allocation of only 11% has remained largely uninspiring given that it has not addressed the critical issues that we raised in our Pre-Budget position paper. It falls far short of the Abuja Declaration Target of 15%.

Unfortunately the health budget remains grossly inadequate to address the critical needs in the health sector such as the current exodus of health workers, drug shortages, inadequate ambulances, and obsolete equipment.

The inadequate public financing of the health sector has resulted in an overreliance on out-of-pocket and external financing which is highly unsustainable.

We hope that the funds allocated will be timeously and fully disbursed to the health sector and that the Ministry of Health will also utilize the funds effectively and in a transparent manner.

I hope this will assist

Itai Rusike, Executive Director, Community Working Group on Health (CWGH)

CWGH Annual General Meeting Link for Network Members

Dear CWGH Network Members,

Greetings. I hope you are well

    1. This communications serves as a reminder to attend the Annual General Meeting of the Members of CWGH virtually today – Thursday, 24th November 2022 from 1000hrs to 1230hrs. Please see below the meeting link

https://teams.microsoft.com/l/meetup-join/19%3ameeting_ZDlhYTI0NTctMjI5NC00ODBmLTg4ZjYtYWVjYzIzOWE4NjJh%40thread.v2/0?context=%7b%22Tid%22%3a%22f5411472-d0f4-44eb-a8d4-b429984cea85%22%2c%22Oid%22%3a%22c028a3af-6e8c-4760-9ff2-cf5a7f2640f5%22%7d

 

AGENDA OF THE NATIONAL ANNUAL GENERAL MEETING

To receive, consider and adopt the:

· Minutes of the previous AGM

· Annual report by the Chairperson

· Annual Audit Report by the Treasurer

· Election of the Executive Committee

BY ORDER OF THE EXECUTIVE COMMITTEE

CWGH Press Statement for World Pneumonia Day – 12 November 2022 – Harare, Zimbabwe

Theme: Fighting Pneumonia an Agenda for Action
Zimbabwe successfully implemented Primary Health Care since its independence in 1980. As a result, impactful programmes with a deliberate focus on maternal and child health greatly improved health indicators for mothers and children up to 2000. Slackening of this momentum was caused by several challenges; notably the structural adjustment programmes of the 1980’s, the HIV and AIDS pandemic, sustained under funding for health, (below the 15% Abuja target of government budget to health), management and governance problems, all resulting in marked decline in health services provision. All these have since contributed to high morbidity and mortality rates especially for women and children under five.
Respiratory infections have increased and maternal and neonatal conditions remain a major driver of disability-adjusted life years, (DALYs). Globally more than 670 000 children under the age of five die of pneumonia, surpassing infectious disease and conditions such as HIV, malaria and tuberculosis annually.
The top four causes of DALYs in Zimbabwe are respiratory infections, HIV/AIDS, maternal & neonatal issues and cardiovascular disease. Pneumonia in Zimbabwe as in other low income countries is caused by viruses, bacteria, especially streptococcus pneumonia, fungi, and preexisting conditions such as malnutrition, HIV, measles, asthma, diabetes, among other underlying factors.
The majority of pneumonias in children are both preventable and manageable. However, for a country with multiple health challenges this may not have been adequately prioritized, quantified and qualified to make meaningful interventions particularly those aimed at the household or community. Until recently the medicines policy of the country did not allow community based workers to store and dispense antibiotics, anti-virals or antifungals to treat commonly occurring pneumonias in children.
Meanwhile environmental factors such as poor hygiene, poor water and sanitation, air pollution, (indoor and outdoor), cigarette smoke, also predispose to pneumonias in children. The health delivery system has in the past decade been on a marked decline in health services provision and the most vulnerable remain the children and their mothers who are major users of the health system;
 Compounded by the Covid-19 pandemic, there has been reduced access and utilization of health services, with downsizing of services at most clinics, district, provincial and central hospitals, while several clinics in Harare closed for lack of staff, medicine and supplies for most of 2022.  This imposes a heavy burden on the mothers, families and communities on managing the prevalent childhood diseases such as pneumonia.  Using this opportunity offered by World Pneumonia Day, we wish to stimulate the investment in community health as an integral component of PHC by empowering the mothers, families and communities to identify and manage pneumonia in the home and community. Working in close liaison with their health facility staff, they should be capacitated know the effective local remedies, the harmful practices, and where to get medicines for treating simple cases to minimize complications and deaths. The mothers and caregivers working with the community health workers must know and detect the danger and warning signs and make the right actions that save lives, and make the referrals and accompaniments to the health facility.  The week long commemoration of pneumonia awareness offers us an opportunity to identify all stakeholders for working together to quantify and begin to halt the pneumonia deaths in the under-fives in Zimbabwe, among them; Mothers and caregivers, policy makers, pediatricians, nurses, environmental health workers, nutritionists, nurse aides, health center committees and hospital advisory boards, village health workers, other community based workers, community leaders, media, traditional and spiritual healers.  We will therefore use the World Pneumonia Day to advocate for policies and programmes that improve access to diagnosis and management of pneumonia at household and community level, and ensure continuum of care at all health facilities.  To agree on the urgency of addressing this challenge and adopt the right strategies to prevent, diagnose and treat (deploy the right anti-microbials to community based workers) to improve access before complications and deaths due to untreated pneumonias. This means exploring community deployment of antibiotics, with insistence on rational use against a background of medicines shortages at the health facilities and the increasing challenge of anti-microbial resistance  To utilize pneumonia detection and management at community level to strengthen Primary Health Care implementation for the attainment of Universal Health Coverage and health systems strengthening in Zimbabwe  We therefore advocate for the identification of policies and guidelines that support the detection, diagnosis and management of pneumonia at community level, including access to the right anti-microbials, cognizant of the threat of abuse, misuse, development of anti-microbial resistance against the current high deaths from lack of access to anti-microbials especially antibiotics. There is need for quantification of the burden of pneumonia among children under five for consensus on the local interventions aimed at preventing, diagnosing and management of childhood pneumonia. We will continue to advocate for more research into preventing and managing pneumonias and aim for its elimination as a public health problem.
Author: Itai Rusike (Mr) Executive Director Community Working Group on Health (CWGH

Feature: Surviving breast cancer in today’s environment

Credit: Newsday

SIMBISAI Chiume (not real name) still recalls the distressing events of 2009 when she was diagnosed with breast cancer.

For several women diagnosed with cancer in Zimbabwe, it sounds like a death sentence, but Chiume’s experience with cancer displays the possibility of survival if treatment is administered early.

She has lived as a cancer survivor for 13 years, and she narrates her ordeal for the benefit of other women.

“As I was taking my regular bath in 2009, I observed a small hard lump on one of my breasts. It felt so hard like a stone. At first I ignored it, but the following day I touched my breast again and still felt the hardness. My mother-in-law instantly advised me to go for tests.

“I live at a farm in Chegutu, were I am mostly busy farming. I then decided that I will visit the doctor the following week in Harare. That same week I started experiencing shortness of breath, that is when I visited a general practitioner who recommended that I go for a mammogram,” Chiume said.

She had to undergo a biopsy where a piece of tissue or a sample of cells was removed from her body so that it could be tested in a laboratory for cancer.

“It was a small surgery, and the samples were taken to a laboratory in South Africa. The results came after three weeks. I was scared and anxious. The doctor had a very sad look on his face as he told me and my mother who had accompanied me that I had cancer and needed to undergo surgery in a few days to remove the breast. I went numb before bursting into tears. I was still in my 30s.”

“I was in shock and my relatives had to gather and decide what was in my best interest. I had no medical aid and the sugery was urgent. The operation to remove my breast was going to take about two hours and after surgery, it was difficult to accept that I had lost a breast,” Chiume said.

“I was then referred to an oncologist, Anna Mary Nyakabau. Back then there were only two oncologists in the country. Nyakabau’s intern Nomsa Tsikayi had a very positive attitude, which I attribute to the hope that I had of full recovery.”

Chiume said a very positive attitude was pivotal for cancer patients to fully recover.

“Tsikayi told me that I had to undergo chemotherapy, and explained that I would be taking heavy drugs and experiencing several side effects after treatment; such as the possibility of loss of hair, emotional breakdown, going into early menopause and that I might not have any more kids. I did go through 95% of these symptoms, but Tsikayi had counselled me well.

“I went to chemotherapy at St Annes Hospital in Harare for six months and it was not pleasant. Later I went for radiotherapy and I have lived to tell my story. The procedure was very expensive.”

“What haunted me during chemotherapy was that during each visit we would get reports that one of our colleagues undergoing chemotherapy had passed on. I was blessed that my husband was supportive. ”

Chiume said radiotherapy was not as painful as chemotherapy, but the problem was obsolete machinery, which resulted in cancer patients often going back home unattended to.

“Radiotherapy was supposed to take only one month, but it took me three months to complete the sessions because of equipment shortage. We would also go for routine heart checks. I met my mother’s friend who had one of her breasts removed and it gave me hope that I would survive. As a survivor, I now only go for a mammogram and CT (computerised tomography) scan every two years. It is imperative to have a positive attitude.”

She notes that there is a lot of stigma associated with cancer as patients experience hair loss, weight loss, early menopause, and dark gums, among other side effects.

“People think it is actually a white man’s disease, but it can happen to anyone. If one clocks five years after treatment, chances of the cancer recurring become low. Now I am able to carry heavy loads, I can work like every other person. I watch my diet and avoid fizzy drinks, eat less salt, sugar, and during chemotherapy, it is important to avoid crowds to prevent other infections. We have to maintain a positive attitude and avoid stereotypes. My message to women is that they should frequently get screened because if detected early, cancer can be treated unlike when it has spread. It is not wise to seek treatment at a stage when one is bed-ridden.”

Chiume is one of the few cancer survivors that are now activists in a bid to encourage other women to seek early treatment. She joins women in Chegutu in a cancer awareness campaign, which is aimed at teaching women about breast and cervical cancer, as part of commemorations of the Breast Cancer Month.

Organiser of the Chegutu #PinkOctober event, Sarah Mnyamane said it would be a breast cancer talk, which would be attended by cancer survivors in the town, counsellors, women and members of the medical profession.

“The key issues to be discussed include the high cost of cancer treatment, unavailability of psychological support, and lack of support for women who have lost their breasts to get artificial ones. Women that have lost breasts due to breast cancer should fall under the category of people with disabilities. We will also advocate for grants for cancer survivors of up to US$50 per month to assist them get treatment and  that women diagnosed with cancer should get free services.” Mnyamane said.

Public health expert and executive director of the Community Working Group on Health, Itai Rusike said there was need for the country to emphasise preventive care as the most cost-effective intervention.

“Thirty to 40% of cancers are preventable by avoiding certain known risk factors. The main factors contributing to the increasing incidents of cancer in Zimbabwe include infectious agents, increasing tobacco use, harmful alcohol use, unhealthy diets, physical inactivity, and environmental factors. 80% to 90% of cancer patients present at an advanced stage when management is more costly and treatment outcomes poorer. This is mainly due to lack of access to early detection compounded by human and material resource constraints,” Rusike said.

On treatment, Rusike said Zimbabwe had two functional public health centres offering diagnosis and treatment facilities for cancer; the Parirenyatwa Hospital Radiotherapy Centre in Harare serving mainly the northern region, and Mpilo Hospital Radiotherapy Centre serving mostly the southern region.

“Unfortunately, cancer treatment machines for radiotherapy at our two public health institutions have not been working for over a year now, exposing cancer patients to exhorbitant health expenditure. Only a few privileged Zimbabweans with the financial resources such as the political elite can afford to travel outside the country for specialist cancer treatment in South Africa, India and China while the majority of poor cancer patients have to just wait to die at home,” Rusike said.

He said a majority of cancer patients were uninsured, or under-insured, hence they could not afford private health institutions.

“We need a well-defined and well-crafted national health insurance scheme, and that our government should finance health beyond the 15% of the national budget as prescribed by the Abuja declaration,” he said.