Concerns over amendments to the Health Services Act.

Credit : Newsday

THERE are fears that the recently signed Health Service Amendment Act could trample on the rights of health workers.

Speaking to NewsDay, Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike  said the Act is neither democratic nor consultative.

He said workers in the public health sector  are now disadvantaged in several ways, since now they cannot strike and bargain collectively.

“It is unfortunate that health workers are caught in the middle of a system that is slow to respond to their needs and ethical pressures not to take collective job action,” Rusike said.

“The unpopular Health Services Act will most likely exacerbate the exodus of health workers from the country thereby putting extra pressure on those who will remain on their jobs.”

He urged government to address the conditions of service for health workers to plug the brain drain.

While there are no exact statistics on the number of health professionals who left the country in 2021, the Zimbabwe Nurses Association put the figure at just over 2000.

Last year, government announced plans to ban doctors and nurses from embarking on job action lasting more than three days under new proposed amendments to the Health Services Act.

Fears over Health Service Act amendments

Credits: Newsday By Staff Reporter | Jan. 11, 2023

THERE are fears that the recently signed Health Service Amendment Act could trample on the rights of health workers.

Speaking to NewsDay, Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike  said the Act is neither democratic nor consultative.

 

 

He said public health sector workers are now disadvantaged in several ways because they have no right to strike and they cannot engage in collective bargaining.

“It is unfortunate that health workers are caught in the middle of a system that is slow to respond to their needs and ethical pressures not to take collective job action,” Rusike said.

“The unpopular Health Services Act will most likely exacerbate the exodus of health workers from the country thereby putting extra pressure on those who will remain on their jobs.”

 

 

He urged government to address the conditions of service for health workers to plug the brain drain.

While there are no exact statistics on the number of health professionals who left the country in 2021, the Zimbabwe Nurses Association put the figure at just over 2000.

Last year, government announced plans to ban doctors and nurses from embarking on job action lasting more than three days under new proposed amendments to the Health Services Act.

The Health Services Act was enacted in February 2005 to provide for the establishment of the Health Services Board (HSB) and the transfer of persons engaged in public health service delivery from the Public Service Commission to the HSB.

 

 

Under the Act,, worker representatives who face charges of inciting  nurses and doctors to unlawfully down tools could be jailed for three years in what authorities argue is necessary to ostensibly “instil discipline” in the health sector.

Call for equitable health access

Credit Venessa Gonye : Zimbabwe Independent

HEALTH experts have called for equitable health access for marginalised groups such as rural people, women and children.

This comes as the world yesterday commemorated the International Universal Health Coverage (UHC) Day, which falls on December 12 annually.

Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said a country’s health system should work for everyone regardless of their financial status.

“Equitable health coverage puts women, children, adolescents, and the most vulnerable first because they face the most significant barriers to essential care. We all deserve a health system we know will be there for us throughout our lifespan. Trusted health systems provide high-quality services in primary care clinics and hospitals, equip and support frontline community health workers, and offer transparent health,” Rusike said.

He said Zimbabwe was affected by a decline in standards at the country’s major referral hospital, as well as the brain-drain in key personnel.

 

 

“UHC goes hand-in-hand with empowering communities to build healthy environments that promote holistic physical, mental and social well-being. Investing in #HealthForAll is the backbone of a prosperous society. Increasing public financing for health and reducing out-of-pocket health costs save lives, build resilience against pandemic threats, and advances Sustainable Development Goals beyond health.

World Health Organization (WHO) director AMR Global Co-ordination Haileyesus Getahun said challenges threatening a “healthy future for all” could not be addressed by the healthcare sector alone, but by a united and collaborative multi-sectoral response to ensure health security for everyone.

“The one health approach is an integrated, unifying approach that aims to sustainably balance and optimize the health of people, animals, and ecosystems. It recognizes that the health of humans, domestic and wild animals, plants, and the wider environment (including ecosystems) are closely linked and interdependent,” Getahun said.

In August this year, WHO expressed concern over Zimbabwe’s slow pace in improving UHC, which is part of an initiative to ensure everyone has access to proper health services.

2023 Health Budget insufficient

HEALTH experts yesterday said Finance minister Mthuli Ncube’s $473,8 billion budget allocation towards the provision of health care services was grossly inadequate to fund the sector’s critical needs.

Ncube announced a $4,5 trillion budget on Thursday with 11% going towards health. Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said the health sector remains grossly underfunded.

“The health budget remains grossly inadequate to fund the critical needs in the health sector,” Rusike said.

“The current health financing model remains unsustainable as it heavily relies on external financing as well as out-of-pocket spending.”

“In spite of the huge external support from development partners, there is still a huge financing gap in the health sector in the country which calls for greater innovation and commitment by the government to sustainably address it.”

Dental Private Practitioners Association of Zimbabwe president Johannes Marisa said: “The health sector budget is an improvement from last year but of course when you are benchmarking with the Abuja Declaration you still realise that it falls short of the stipulated 15%.

“We hope the budget is going to address the mass brain drain that is underway in Zimbabwe where we are losing experienced and skilled workers to greener pastures.”

In April 2001, African Union countries met in Abuja and pledged to allocate at least 15% of their annual budgets to improve the health sector and urged donor countries to scale up support.

Years of underfunding of the country’s health sector was laid bare when COVID-19 hit the country as acute shortages of critical and lifesaving equipment such as ventilators and intensive care beds were exposed.

 

Some South African officials have accused Zimbabweans of straining that country’s health sector.

In his 2023 national budget, Ncube the allocation to health was meant to improve health provision.

 “In 2023, the budget has set aside 11% of total expenditures towards the health sector notwithstanding financial constraints, Government is committed to the provision of quality health services, as evidenced by the ongoing construction and rehabilitation of health facilities,” Ncube said.

 “In 2023, the budget has set aside 11% of total expenditures towards the health sector and the objective is to eventually meet the Abuja Declaration of 15%. This is necessary to attain Vision 2030 of becoming an upper middle-income economy.”

“In 2023, the sector is projected to receive US$212,9 million from the development partners towards the same areas.”

Ncube admitted that the health sector has been hard hit by mass exodus of health professionals.

“Government is, however, addressing this challenge through continuous review of both monetary and non-monetary incentives in order to attract and retain medical personnel.”

Schools May Become Hotspots For Measles – Health Expert

Health experts have expressed that schools may be superspreaders of measles, with the disease spreading rapidly countrywide since it was detected in Mutasa District on 10 April this year.

As of 6 September 2022, the Ministry of Health and Childcare had recorded 6 551 cumulative cases, including 4 633 recoveries and 704 deaths across the country.

Zimbabwe Nurses Association (ZINA) president Enock Dongo told NewsDay that there is a high chance of measles spreading like a wildfire in schools. He said:

There is no guarantee for safety, especially in rural areas and other children where they are crowded.

What it means is that the chances of them spreading to each other are very high, especially considering how virulent it is.

So we have no guarantee that this is not going to spread. People should be vaccinated to avoid the chances of hospitalisation and death.

Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said:

We want to continue encouraging parents and guardians to have all children vaccinated against measles in order to avoid schools becoming the epicentre or hotspot for measles.

Westview Clinics boss, Dr Johannes Marisa, said the government should educate people on the importance of being vaccinated against the disease. He said:

We are worried that schools have opened while the situation is like this where measles is spreading like veld fire.

So at this juncture, we should fight vaccine hesitancy by removing all myths around measles.

Disinformation and misinformation surrounding issues of measles are contributing to the law uptake of the vaccines.

Recently, the World Health Organisation (WHO) noted that measles had been progressing quickly and the case fatality was relatively higher when compared to other recent outbreaks.

Government must intensify measles awareness and vaccination campaigns

Government must intensify measles awareness and vaccination campaigns

The Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) has urged the government to intensify measles vaccination and awareness campaigns to prevent further deaths as the highly contagious disease continues to claim lives  countrywide.

By Staff Reporter

In a statement, CWGH Executive Director, Mr Itai Rusike said, “…the worrying statistics from the Ministry of Health and Child Care (MoHCC) indicate that since the measles outbreak in Mutasa district in Manicaland province last month about 700 people, mainly from the religious sects that do not believe in vaccination, have succumbed to the disease.

“More depressing is the fact that the disease, which is preventable by vaccination, has since spread to other parts of the country, killing more people mainly children. With the opening of schools this week, there are fears that the highly contagious disease could rapidly spread across the country, claiming more lives as children from different areas and beliefs mix and mingle in education institutions.”

Government should therefore urgently strengthen its surveillance, control and management procedures to avoid an explosion of the disease in schools.

This also calls on the government to roll-out serious awareness and vaccination campaigns countrywide, including engaging leaders of apostolic sects to ensure they get their children vaccinated to prevent these avoidable deaths.

It is only through reaching out to religious leaders, who command a lot of respect and influence among their congregants that the majority of their followers can agree to get their children vaccinated against measles and other killer diseases.

Informative messages and materials should be printed and distributed where community 
members who are at risk are likely to have access to them.

It is important to note that partnership among the public health sector, civil society and media is critical for successful implementation of public health activities. For that reason, we urge the government to roll-out serious awareness campaigns against measles on television, radio, newspapers, social media platforms and carrying out road shows in the affected areas to ensure that the message reaches out to all citizens to prevent further deaths. One death is too many.

Parents and guardians must also play a pivotal role in the fight against measles. It is inexcusable that, in this time and age, children continue to die from measles and other diseases that are preventable or that should have been eradicated decades ago.

Measles outbreak looms in schools

THE reopening of schools amid a major measles outbreak countrywide might expose learners who are not vaccinated as Zimbabwe battles to control the disease, health experts have warned.

Statistics from the Health and Child Care ministry show that 153 new cases were recorded on Tuesday while fatalities climbed to 698 from 685.

Cumulative and active cases are now at 6 444 and 4 580, respectively.

Zimbabwe Nurses Association president Enock Dongo expressed fear that schools might be super-spreaders of the medieval disease if pupils are not vaccinated.

“There is no guarantee for safety especially in rural areas and other children where they are crowded. What it means is that the chances of them spreading to each other are very high, especially considering how virulent it is,” Dongo said.

“So we have no guarantee that this is not going to spread. People should be vaccinated to avoid chances of hospitalization and death.”

Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said government should strengthen community surveillance and awareness.

“We want to continue encouraging parents and guardians to have all children vaccinated against measles in order to avoid schools becoming the epicenter or hotspot for measles,” Rusike said.

 

Another health expert, Johannes Marisa said the government should educate people so that they can make informed decisions because most people are skeptical about vaccines.

“We are worried that schools have opened while the situation is like this where measles is spreading like veldfire. So at this juncture we should fight vaccine hesitancy by removing all myths around measles.  Disinformation and misinformation surrounding issues of measles is contributing to the law uptake of the vaccines,” Marisa said.

Zimbabwe Senior Hospital Doctors Association president Shingai Nyaguse-Chiurunge concurred saying gathering of unvaccinated people, especially in the apostolic sects is a cause for concern.

The outbreak started in April in Manicaland and has since spread across the country.

More than 50% of the registered cases had not been vaccinated.

The World Health Organization warned in April about the increase in measles cases in vulnerable countries as a result of a disruption of services due to COVID-19.

Community health workers: Essential for health, under-valued by planners

Community health workers (CHWs) were key to Zimbabwe`s successful expansion of primary health care (PHC) in the early 1980`s. CHWs played a central role in closing the gap between public health services and communities at local levels, bringing health services outreach to communities, and facilitating community roles in the health delivery system. For example, CHWs and Community Based Distributors were instrumental in implementing the successful Zimbabwe Family Planning Programme, as they helped raise awareness on family planning methods such as condoms and combined oral contraceptives (commonly known as “The Pill”), as well as the advantages of child spacing. These efforts are reflected in the expansion of coverage of contraception and reported decrease in fertility rates in the country from 6.5 children per woman in the early 1980`s to 4.3 children per woman in 2001.

CHWs continue up to today to augment the work being done by the mainstream health sector, raising awareness, giving health advice, monitoring growth of children under five years, mobilizing communities during out-reach programmes and for immunization including as trusted sources of information for community literacy on Covid-19.

 


Community health workers reflect on their work

Mrs. Kaseke a CHW in Mwanza Ward (Goromonzi District in Zimbabwe) echoes these sentiments. One of her roles as a CHW is to mobilize food for chronically ill and home based patients in her area. She also runs community based growth monitoring clinics on Saturdays. “I have a scale that was allocated to me by the clinic when I started as a CHW. Women from my area bring their babies at my homestead. I weigh the babies and record their weight on cards, as it is done at the clinic. I then use the weight records to check if the child is growing well; otherwise I refer the child to the clinic for further assessment”.

CHWs see an important role for themselves in bridging the gap between the community and the health services, as explained by another Village Health Worker from Mangwe District in Zimbabwe, Mrs. Portia Moyo:

‘We are the link between the community and the health department. We advise and refer the community to seek medical attention early, care for the home based ridden patients, chronic and TB patients on DOTS’.

CHWs and Community Based Distributors were instrumental in implementing the successful Zimbabwe Family Planning Programme, as they helped raise awareness on family planning methods such as condoms and combined oral contraceptives (commonly known as “The Pill”), as well as the advantages of child spacing.

Low morale or lack of support?

Despite these vital functions, the numbers of CHWs and the role played by CHWs has diminished over the past two decades in Zimbabwe. Whilst communities cite low morale due to lack of incentives as the major setback, the CHWs and other health staff point to lack of incentives and supporting resources and protective equipment as a major barrier to their performance.

In their early years, Community Health Workers benefited from incentives from the National Health Budget such as uniforms, bicycles and allowances, which were meant to enhance their work and motivate them. Bicycles were both a token of appreciation, and a tool to enable these volunteers to take their services to a wider population. The allowances they received helped them to buy basic necessities such as soap, so that they could look presentable whilst they carried out their duties. These incentives are now a thing of the past as there is no provision in our current national health budget to support CHWs hence the overreliance on external donors. There is urgent need to invest in Community Health Workers, increasing domestic health financing and move away from the current heavy reliance on external donors as it is not sustainable and poses a security threat in the event that donors decide to pull out for whatever reason.

Highlighting the plight of Community Health Workers, Mrs. Moyo said:

‘We as Community Health Workers’ are surprised about how we are handled…the problem is, out of all these duties our allowances are still as low as US$15 per month of which it is received after 3 to 6 months… We Community Health Workers are very much exposed to the world of infection, because we do not have protective clothing to put on when attending to home-based patients, of which most of them may have open wounds…We have tried in vain to request these protective clothing from our district hospital but the response is disheartening.’

There is urgent need to invest in Community Health Workers, increasing domestic health financing and move away from the current heavy reliance on external donors as it is not sustainable and poses a security threat in the event that donors decide to pull out for whatever reason.

Whilst communities cite low morale due to lack of incentives as the major setback, the CHWs and other health staff point to lack of incentives and supporting resources and protective equipment as a major barrier to their performance.

We as civil society demand more support for CHWs

Revitalizing CHW roles have been proposed as one measure to deal with the gap in health worker numbers in the face of the brain drain of health workers from rural to urban areas and from developing to developed nations. CHWs do not replace the requirement for adequate trained staff at primary and district levels of health systems, but they are a key cadre in the health system-fully aware of the health needs and aspirations of their communities. This makes them an invaluable asset in advancing community-orientated health delivery, and they should be supported.

The Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) has thus urged government to work with other stakeholders to create a plan to fully fund the CHW programme and support their work and to ensure that adequate resources are allocated in the budget for CHWs are accessible and reach these community level cadres for their work. However, this is not just a matter for government.

As civil society we see that the presence of VHWs in our communities is essential in our quest for equity in health and accessibility of health services, so that we too will be part of this support, including documenting the roles and impacts of CHWs our community to engage government and other stakeholders to value and resource these roles in the spirit of health for all.

The CWGH has thus urged government to work with other stakeholders to create a plan to fully fund the CHW programme and support their work and to ensure that adequate resources are allocated in the budget for CHWs are accessible and reach these community level cadres for their work.

The Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) is a network of membership based civic organizations focusing on advocacy, action and networking around health issues in Zimbabwe. www.cwgh.co.zw

Itai Rusike

Itai Rusike is a Public Health Activist with more than 20 years’ experience organizing involvement of communities in health actions in Zimbabwe. He is also an active member of several regional and international organisations including national statutory bodies. Twitter @itairusike Email