Public Health Act (Amendment) Bill: Community participation crucial

Itai Rusike Correspondent
The opportunity afforded to Zimbabweans to provide input into the supreme health law of the country is refreshing.
It is important to have communities come out and participate during the public hearings on the Public Health Act (Amendment) Bill to ensure that their views and perceptions have been incorporated into the final Bill and that it addresses community needs as enshrined in the nation’s Constitution.
Following a number of public health blunders that have seen resurgence of previously controlled diseases, unnecessary death, disability and suffering of Zimbabweans, it is imperative to have a shared vision and mission for public health across national stakeholders, including a shared understanding of the purposes and objectives of a public health law and the scope of public health action.
The role of communities should be to demand environmental, infrastructure and structural provisions to promote health for all in urban, rural, farming, mining and institutional spaces.
Zimbabweans must use this opportunity to ensure the development of a law that is not simply a means for controlling nuisances, but a tool for promotion of healthy conditions, for co-ordination of health activities and for improving the dialogue and relationships across public health authorities for the attainment of the country’s vision and mission for the health and well-being of its citizens.
In the developed world, health promotion is a high national priority that sits in the Prime Minister’s Office and ensures the provision of a healthy environment for all citizens and the attainment of health in its totality through targeted initiatives such as healthy cities, lifestyles, food etc.
Community concerns regarding gaps in the gazetted Public Health Act (Amendment) Bill
Community level mechanisms and functions
• Although Health Centre Committees (HCCs) have been legally recognised in Section 17, they are not represented in the District Health Team in Section 16 for feedback to and from the communities. Therefore, we strongly recommend that community involvement mechanisms need a representation mechanism in the district health team as the district government council in addition to the hospital management board, which oversees functionality of the district hospital.
• HCCs were fully captured. However the role of Village Health Workers (VHWs) and other community-based workers is not satisfactorily and explicitly stated in the act except for Section 137 sub-section 1(b) in a general statement that says “The minister may make regulations providing for: Recognising and providing for the roles of non-state actors and communities. Thus provisions for the VHWs could be detailed soon after Section 17 of HCCs.
• This is important because VHWs do not have an association or representation like other health cadres and yet they are the backbone of all community health programmes, hence the need for legal backing in order to be given priority. Include specific inclusion of the broad roles and functions of VHWs, including how they relate to other community-based workers (home-based carers, family planning distributors, OI/ART/Dots coordinators, school health coordinators, malaria spray operators etc)
• Section 28: The Bill is silent on the Health Centre staff establishment. It is therefore crucial to have a specific clause in the Bill that speaks to issues of the ideal healthcare establishment that looks realistically to the country attaining universal health coverage and the SDGs given that the current staff establishment was determined using the 1982 population statistics and when the disease burden was very low.
• Although it is covered in the Health Services Act, it should still reflect in the Public Health Act (Amendment) Bill so that the two are harmonised and be in tandem with the Constitutional provisions of leaving no one behind.
• Section 3: The Minister of Health and Child Care as a competent authority and the custodian of the Public Health Act should enforce the Act by demonstrating adequate powers supported with resources than has been the case under the current law.
The minister requires the legal muscle and needs teeth to bite so that perennial offenders of well-articulated and scientifically proven public health provisions, interventions and standards, such as the City of Harare, other local authorities and individuals can be brought to book and potential public health disasters averted before loss of life as has so far been the case and without fear or favour.
Itai Rusike is the executive director for the Community Working Group on Health

Health ministry bemoans poor budget

HARARE – The health sector’s $520 million 2018 budget allocation remains too low, despite Finance minister Patrick Chinamasa having increased it from $454 million, Health minister David Parirenyatwa said.
He said there was a lot of damage, wear and tear at the hospitals that needs to be fixed.
“Our target was $1,1 billion, it’s still not sufficient if you look at the number of repairs that are needed in our hospitals, just as an example.
“Before I touch medicines, if you look at how many laundry machines countrywide have broken down, the X-Ray machines that need to be replaced, the laboratory equipment that need to be addressed. Parirenyatwa said.
“We cannot replace all the laundry machines in all the hospitals in one year; we need to phase it and all that needs a big budget, so that budget to me is insufficient.”
Zimbabwe’s hospitals have been crippled by lack of medicines and equipment, which has in the past resulted in the suspension of some surgical operations at some major hospitals.
In trying to solve the situation, government introduced a health tax on airtime to boost revenue collection for drugs and equipment procurement, which according to Parirenyatwa has so far fetched $22 million.
Community Working Group on Health executive director Itai Rusike said the revised budget allocations were not adequate to meet a lot of challenges and that it still fell below “the Abuja Target of 15 percent of national budget that should be allocated to the health ministry.
“Access to allocated funds has also remained an issue in previous years as a result of limited flows of funds into the fiscus and other issues to do with absorption of funds.
“However, the need to prioritise the health sector when funds are disbursed from the fiscus has to be emphasised with the ministry of Finance,” he said.
“Civil society organisations have advocated for a pro-poor budget and a budget that promotes the principles of primary health care while moving towards the realisation of universal health coverage. We have also advocated for budget policies that reflects the country’s commitments to the international laws, norms and commitments such as the Right to Health, the Abuja Target and the Sustainable Development Goals.”

Govt to subsidise healthcare for the vulnerable

Dr Gwinji
Dr Gwinji

Government will use the Health Levy, which has so far received $22 million, to supply vital medicines and medical sundries required by health institutions to implement the free user-fee policy for vulnerable groups, Health and Child Care Secretary Dr Gerald Gwinji has said.

The Health Levy is money realised from a 10 percent cellphone levy deducted from every $1 worth of airtime which was introduced by Treasury last year, half of which is channelled towards health.

Responding to questions on Government’s source of funding for a successful free user-fee policy, which has been in existence since 1980 but was not being implemented due to inadequate funding by Government for health institutions, Dr Gwinji said medicines and medical sundries consume the bulk of institutions’ budgets.

He said a mechanism was required to meet costs of medical care for the elderly, children under five years of age and pregnant women following a recent directive by his ministry to all institutions to ensure that patients in these categories did not pay for basic health care.

“The main challenge for implementation has been availing commodities and equipment in the face of low budgetary support. It is true that some mechanism must pay for this service when it is eventually availed as free service to the identified patients,” said Dr Gwinji.

Dr Gwinji said Government, together with its partners, had over the years strategised and built support for the care of children under five years and pregnant women. He said the main issues in addressing these challenges had always been provision of medical commodities.

“The Health Levy, dedicated to commodities like medicines and surgical sundries, has come in to further strengthen this position,” said Dr Gwinji.

He said this year, the health sector also got a better budgetary allocation compared to previous years, which he said would enable the free user-fee policy to become a reality.

“Putting all this together, we feel we have gone over the threshhold where we really can support the categories (the elderly, pregnant women and children under five) with access to service as per Government policy,” he said.

Medicines, vaccines and other consumables worth over $11 million have already been ordered. Dr Gwinji said Government would however continue to advocate for adequate funding for social welfare to enable the health sector to effectively assist other patients outside these categories but were unable to meet the costs of medical care.

Dr Gwinji said going forward, if the current health financing policy was supported, it could create further opportunities for sustainable health care financing through diverse sources of revenue spelt out in the policy. The health financing policy gave birth to cellphone taxation and has other suggestions for mobilisation of domestic financial resources.

Health institutions contacted for comment on the scrapping of the user-fee policy said they had already effected the directive. Harare Central Hospital chief executive officer Mrs Peggy Zvavamwe said: “So far, everything is going on well and we have been assured that we will also get extra allocations to cover costs of these identified patients, who are no longer paying for medical care.”

She concurred with Dr Gwinji that medicines and medical sundries consumed the bulk of their budgets and that should Government meet these costs for the vulnerable groups, the burden would be lighter for health institution in the country. Community Working Group of Health executive director Mr Itai Rusike said while the free user-fee policy had always been in place, its implementation got mixed at various levels of care.

He said in some instances, patients would receive free consultation fees but would have to pay for medicines or other required services. Mr Rusike implored Government to increase funding for health including grants, for the country to effectively implement its policies.

Paidamoyo Chipunza Senior Health Reporter January 5, 2018

Health expenditure continues to dwindle

ZIMBABWE will this year spend a measly $25 per person on health, while government expenditure on health continues to fail to reach the 11,3% of Sub-Saharan Africa’s average, and 15% of the national budget as stipulated by the Abuja Declaration.
BY VENERANDA LANGA
The amount of $25 that government will spend on each person this year is a drastic drop from $62 per capita in 2013 (World Health Organisation statistics) which government spent per person, and $58 per capita in 2014, as well as $48 per capita in 2011.
The figures show that health allocations per capita in Zimbabwe have drastically dwindled in the past years.
Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) executive director Itai Rusike, in a post-budget analysis, said government allocations on health had continued to be low (7,7% of the total health budget).
This, however, is a slight increase from 6,7% in 2016, but it is still inadequate as the health infrastructure needs serious rehabilitation, as well as the acute shortage of drugs that patients experience at health institutions in the country.
In the 2018 National Budget statement, Finance minister Patrick Chinamasa allocated $408 million to health, while more money was allocated to Defence ($420m), Home Affairs ($435m), Lands and Agriculture ($497m), and the highest allocation went to Primary and Secondary Education ($905m).
“Per capita (per individual person) health expenditure in the country is insufficient to guarantee adequate access and quality of healthcare as per capita health allocation stands at about $25 in 2018, up from $22 in 2017 and about $24 in 2016,” Rusike said.
“Per capita health spending is $650 (US dollars) in South Africa, $90 in Zambia and $200 in Angola, and the inadequate public financing of health has resulted in an overreliance on out-of-pocket and external financing which is highly unsustainable.”
As a result, government would continue to rely on donor funding with development partners expected to pump in $239,6m, with Global Fund injecting $173,8m, Health Development Fund ($58,1m), and Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunisation ($7,7m).
While Zimbabwe continues to fail to fund health care to the Abuja convention stipulations, other countries like Malawi, Rwanda, Madagascar, Togo and Zambia have managed to reach the Abuja
target.
“In Rwanda and Uganda, they drastically reduced defence and security budgets in recent years to allow for scaling up of pro-poor expenditure on human and infrastructure development. Military and security spending have been shown to retard development by diverting government resources that could be put to better use. In fact, development, not military deterrence, is the best strategy for a safer society,” Rusike said.
He said developed countries spend relatively more on health, while poor developing countries like Zimbabwe spend relatively more on defence.
Zimbabwe spends about 6% of gross domestic product (GDP) on defence and security and only 2% on health.
“The United States spends 6,6% of its GDP on health care and only 3,8% of its GDP on defence. Japan spends 1% of its GDP on defence and 6,5% of its GDP on health care. Germany spends 1,4% of its GDP on defence and 8,6% of its GDP on health. Eritrea, on the other hand, spends 19,4% of its GDP on defence and only 3,2% of its GDP on health,” Rusike said.
He said while there was a slight improvement in the 2018 health allocation, it was still inadequate to cover the health needs of Zimbabweans.
Health minister David Parirenyatwa recently said he needed over $1 billion.

CWGH Releases Position Paper On 2018 Budget For Health

The Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) has released its proposed position paper regards the 2018 Budget for health requirements.
Amongst other things, CWGH implored government to allocate at least 15% of the National Budget to health care in line with the Abuja Declaration target.
“Empirical evidence has shown that a 1% increase in public spending on health care reduces child and maternal mortality rates while improving life expectancy.
“To boost public spending on health without undermining fiscal sustainability government must explore a number of options for innovative domestic and sustainable financing. These options include: broadening the tax base through introducing incentives to mainstream the informal sector into the formal economy,” said CWGH.
Other options include corrective and wealth taxes. Enhancing tax administration is also vital.

Allocate foreign currency towards ARV procurement – CWGH

THE Community Working Group on Heath (CWGH), has called on government to prioritise allocation of foreign currency towards the procurement of Anti Retro Viral medicines ARVs amid revelations of massive ARV stock outs at public health centres and pharmacies.

CWGH Executive director Itai Josh Rusike said it was disheartening that Zimbabwe which over the years made tremendous gains in reducing HIV/AIDS related deaths through multi-sectoral efforts, is now experiencing a serious shortage of Abacavir – a second line ARV drug to the extent that people taking that drug are only being given a week's supply instead of the usual three months' provision.

"As an organization whose primary focus is the enjoyment of quality equitable health services, the CWGH would like to urge the government to quickly avail foreign currency for the procurement of ARVs to save thousands of lives that are under threat. The shortages will definitely compromise the health of the 35% of the estimated one million people on second line treatment as they will default on taking their medication.

"Limited availability of ARVs impedes patient initiation, adherence and poses a major barrier to win against the HIV response as a country. It should be emphasised that optimal adherence is essential to ensure individual treatment access and limit viral resistance. Treatment for HIV/AIDS is threatened when ARV drugs are not available, undermining treatment compliance.

The weekly supply of the drugs will force people to commute regularly to their usual collection points thereby incurring heavy out-of-pocket costs, a situation most people will not afford under the current harsh economic situation. Some will fail to collect their drugs leading to defaulting due to prohibitive costs," said Rusike.

He added that even once drugs reach facilities, there are many other barriers to access which include transport charges and fees to use facilities, and the costs of lost work time.

"When drugs are not available in facilities community members may be forced to buy them from private suppliers. The cost of medications have increased significantly and medical care costs have been the highest rising element of the Consumer Price Index for some time. If the current situation is not addressed urgently, the country will end up losing some of the gains recorded over the past years.

It is important that the government secures access to ARVs for the realization of the 90-90-90 objectives; that is to initiate 90% of diagnosed patients and obtain viral suppressing in 90% of those on ART. What is most disturbing is that the shortages of ARVs comes at a time the World Health Organisation (WHO) has warned of a drug resistant HIV as an emerging threat in developing countries."

Meanwhile, drug interruption has been cited for increased cases of this new strain. According to the WHO, rational drug use implies that "patients receive medications appropriate to their clinical needs, in doses that meet their own requirements, for an adequate period of time, and at the lowest cost to them and their community".

"It is professionally unacceptable that the situation was allowed to deteriorate to these levels when the country has the Ministry of Health and Child Care (MoHCC) and the National AIDS Council (NAC), institutions that jointly superintends over the procurement and distribution of the
living-saving drugs. Both institutions must have raised the red flag well before the situation reaches this crisis point if proper monitoring procedures were in place.

"The major constraint to procurement in 2017 has also been the availability of foreign currency to procure ARVs. Foreign currency supplies from the Reserve Bank of Zimbabwe can lag behind for as much as 4-5 months," said Rusike.

Meanhwile, Rusike added that there was need to advocate for more immediate policy attention to be given to significant obstacles in drug access, including foreign currency supplies to Natpharm, timely payment to Natpharm of debts, adequacy of trained pharmacists in government service, improved management of drugs with an information system that provides timely information on drug availability, improved equity in the distribution of available drugs with greater support of drug supplies to primary care level.

"There are a number of factors affecting drug availability. It appears that at primary care level the level and quality of staffing, expertise and resources is currently too low to provide for the basic requirements of a drug procurement and management system. Higher levels of the health system are also not adequately supporting quality and supply in this level of care.

"Resource constraints and foreign currency shortages have also limited supplies at higher levels. There are also shortages due to losses from supplies that have been obtained. This occur when drugs expire or are stolen."

Government spending on health had declined in real terms and is currently concentrated in hospitals, particularly at central level. There is disproportionately high expenditure on staff and health infrastructure as compared to other recurrent inputs such as pharmaceuticals and maintenance, resulting in the general shortage of medical consumables. The shortage of foreign currency has undermined efforts to maintain a supply of affordable ARVs.

There is evidence that drug access has fallen in recent years, and that drug availability is falling, most sharply at the clinic services that form the frontline of the health care system with the community. This represents an unfair cost burden on poor communities, but also opens the way
for the growth of private unregulated drug markets.

Zim’s public health spending lowest in Sadc

GOVERNMENT spending towards health this year averaged a measly $21 per person, a figure that is lower than $24 per person in 2016, the Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) has said.
BY VENERANDA LANGA
In its contribution to the 2018 National Budget consultations, CWGH said the per capita allocation towards health is one of the lowest in the Southern African Development Community (Sadc) region whose average spending on health per person is $146.
“The per capita allocation stands at $21 down from $24 in 2016 and this implies that the government will spend an average of $21 per person on healthcare in 2017,” CWGH executive director, Itai Rusike said.
“The per capita health allocation is lower than the Sadc average of $146 and per capita health allocation in South Africa is $650, Zambia $90, and Angola $200,” he said.
Rusike said the CWGH is also worried about the total budget allocation to health, which has remained lower than the prescribed 15% of the total budget by the Abuja Declaration and the Sadc target of at least 11,3% of the total budget.
“Countries such as Malawi, Rwanda, Madagascar, Togo and Zambia have managed to reach the Abuja Declaration target, according to the World Health Organisation (WHO), and as of 2015, Rwanda spent at least 23% of its budget on healthcare.”
The CWGH said Zimbabwe has however, made significant gains in the area of HIV prevalence, child and maternal mortality, which have significantly dropped.
Rusike, however, railed against the government’s over-dependence on external donor funding for the health sector at 24,9%, although the bulk of health financing is from employers who contribute 28,4% and government at 21,4%.
“The high dependency on external financing is unreliable, unpredictable, unsustainable and highly dependent on the political environment; raising concerns on the sustainability of health financing institutions and the vulnerability of government’s budget should external funds be withdrawn.”
Other problems noted in the health sector include poor infrastructure and ill-equipped hospitals, as well as a worrying ratio of patients to health personnel which stood at 12,7 health workers to 10 000 patients in 2011 (WHO statistics).
The country is also said to be relying heavily on imports for drugs, equipment and other hospital consumables, while some health institutions have inadequate equipment to carry out diagnosis.
The CWGH said the government must broaden the tax base in order to fund health, by for example introducing tobacco tax, or raising taxes on sugar-sweetened beverages to fight non-communicable diseases and even introduce a wealth tax.

Parliament To Boycott 2018 Budget Unless It Meets Abuja Target

The Parliamentary Portfolio committee on Health says it will not entertain a flimsy allocation of funds to the health sector in the forthcoming 2018 budget presentation unless the 15% Abuja target is met.
This was said by Matabeleland North senator Sibusisiwe Budha-Masara at the Pre-budget review workshop organized by the Community Working Group on Health (CWGH) held on Wednesday in Harare.
“I think as a country, this is something that I would want Zimbabweans to consider even though there is little time for you to put your input into this budget. But I think this is the opportunity for us to say whatever we feel the budget must look like because a healthy nation in terms of economic development we need healthy manpower and it is our right that we must receive quality health as citizens of this country,” she said.
She added that health must be prioritized in this year’s budget allocation.
“I think we need to lobby and talk to relevant organisations who can assist us that this budget this time around must pay priority to health,” said the Senator.
Zimbabwe is a signatory to the Abuja Declaration of 2001 in which African Union countries pledged to allocate at least 15 percent of their annual budgets to improving the health sector. Since then, the country is yet to meet the target. In the 2017 budget, the health sector only got 7 percent.
She declared that should the budget miss the Abuja declaration on allocating 15 percent of the National Budget, it risks not seeing the light of day.
“If it does not meet the 15 percent Abuja Declaration, I think we have got all the power to deny it that it cannot be passed as long as health in Zimbabwe is not a priority,” she said.
Binga North MP Prince Dubeko Sibanda sharing his experience in Uganda learnt that if a budget ignores the plight of the marginalized it doesn’t get Parliamentary approval to be passed.
“One thing I took in Uganda, they have got a law which says unless the budget meets certain criteria or takes care of people that are generally marginalized that budget should not be passed. Its part and parcel of their law. Its never passed,” the parliamentarian said.
With just three weeks before the 2018 Budget is announced by the new Finance and Economic development minister Dr Ignatious Chombo, the parliamentary portfolio committee, NGOs expect the treasury to meet the Abuja declaration which states that 15 percent of the National budget should be dedicated to Health to show commitment of ensuring a healthy and productive nation.
Presenting the 2017 national budget year, the then Finance and Economic Development Minister Patrick Chinamasa announced that $281,9 million will be channeled towards the sector inclusive of remuneration for the public health care personnel ($223 million), operations and maintenance ($29,6 million), as well as capital expenditure that has been pegged at $29,5 million.

 

October 11, 2017October 11, 2017 NewsRoom By Kudakwashe Pembere